Donizetti’s Anna Bolena

04_Anna_Bolena_82119_GRITSKOVA_GRUBEROVA The story of Anne Boleyn, second wife of Henry VIII, is endlessly fascinating. How Henry was so infatuated by her, he broke with Rome , and set up the Church of England , to engineer a divorce (from Catherine of Aragon.) Was it because Anne couldn’t bear him a son- only a daughter (to be Elizabeth 1, no less)- that she had to go? Were the revelations of an affair (rather a flirtation) with court musician Smeaton a trumped-up excuse? And the allegation of a ‘secret marriage’, prior to Henry, with Lord Percy, an attempt , by Henry’s advisors, to nullify Henry’s marriage to Anne?
Donizetti’s opera may be an operatic masterpiece. But, artistic imagination fired, he (and librettist Felice Romani) play fast and loose with ‘historical truth’. Whatever the foundation to these amours, Anne’s fate, to be imprisoned and beheaded, is a tragedy, which she forbears with great dignity.

Vienna State Opera’s Anna Bolena is a handsomely mounted period production, (directed by Eric Génovèse.) The superbly constructed stage set (Jacques Gabel) has stone courtyard and pillars depicting Windsor Castle. The lavishly detailed costumes (Luisa Spinatelli), richly authenticated English Renaissance, would justify a Cecil B de Mille Hollywood film set.
The cast excelled, with Edita Gruberova-a legend in Donizetti bel canto roles- in the title role. But Gruberova, in the first Act, sometimes strained in her top notes, sounded a little shrill. Perhaps she was saving herself for the ever-more demanding second Act, which Anna dominates. Here Gruberova, with her stage charisma, triumphed.
And, close-up, (I was close to the stage), I wondered, is she too old to be in the role of a child-bearing woman? But opera is all about the voice, and, as in theatre, we must suspend belief and banish insolent thoughts. Gruberova is a superb actress, as when (Act 1, scene 3,) she fights with all her will to deflect Percy’s advances, he swearing his undying love. (She admits she loves Percy, but rebuffs him, still loyal to Henry.) Here the top notes were a little unstable: the coloratura a roller-coaster ride. Celso Albelo’s Percy, handsomely bearded, has a beautifully rich tenor. Henry VIII (Marco Vinco), who has arranged the apparently chance meeting between Percy and Bolena, hopes to catch them out , so he can accuse Anna of adultery.
In Donizetti’s opera (Romani’s libretto), musician Mark Smeaton (Anna’s page) is supposed to have stolen a miniature of Anna, which he tries to return to the Queen’s chambers, unnoticed! Smeton (sic), mezzo Margarita Gritskova in a ‘trouser role’, makes the complex plot still more complicated. Slightly overacted, but ‘she’ has a boyish face, and the mezzo role is expressively sung. In a potentially farcical situation, Smeton jumps out of hiding , as Percy draws a dagger to kill himself. At which moment Henry enters! Marco Vinco’s Henry (Enrico), is taller than we expect, and, his long hair tied at the back, very elegantly attired in long leather coat and striped tunic. And what stage presence! In contrast to the puerile Smeton, Vinci’s Henry, with his formidable bass, exudes authority. And he’s very sexy.
Henry holds up the medallion and triumphantly shows it to Anna. She pleads, as if kneeling on a couch, while Henry continues to brandish her locket; then he grabs Anna by the arm and pushes her away. The Queen protests fiercely; ironically, she’s been brought down, not by her previous affair with Percy- who’s advances she has now rebuffed- but by a boy’s infatuation. Gruberova’s soprano soars powerfully in the tremendous Act finale, In quegli sguardi impresso . She tries to explain, but Henry will see her in court. Anna! Ai giudici! her last note is almost a shriek of horror.
Anna, now imprisoned-and deprived of her ladies-in-waiting- is visited by Jane (Giovanna) Seymour. Their duet provides one of the greatest scenes in the opera, although Donizetti would have us believe that the astute Queen did not know of Seymour, her lady-in-waiting’s, affair with Henry. In her aria,’ Oh, all-seeing God, have I deserved all this?’ now Gruberova’s in simple white silk, adorned against the gold of her crown. Seymour (mezzo Sonia Ganassi) appears pale, trembling. Awful- appalling: can I bring you happiness? The King is prepared to dissolve her marriage. But his message is, if Anna admits her guilt, he will save her life. – You would advise me to do that? – Do you want disgrace and death, counters Seymour. ‘Who is the ‘miserable woman’ Henry loves? She has brought unhappiness on me! May God punish her! Gruberova is formidable, shatteringly powerful. Now ‘the traitor’ kneels before her. YOU MY RIVAL, YOU MY SEYMOUR!
In this emotionally wrought scene, Seymour (Ganassi) sings, she sighs and weeps, but tears cannot quench her love, (Dal mio cor punita io sono). Ganassi, a high-calibre mezzo, is a match even for Gruberova. These two spark each other off: Götterfunken. Heavenly. Now Anna bids her, Go, unhappy woman, and take Boleyn’s pardon. She offers her compassion and love. He, Henry alone, is guilty. Outstanding duet!
Henry has told Smeton Anna can only be saved by his testifying to having an affair with the Queen. Smeton commits perjury and unwittingly signs his death sentence. With Henry’s discovery that Percy and Anna were previously ‘married’, the Queen will be convicted of multiple adultery.
Vinco’s Henry looks absolutely splendid in white silk, intricately patterned, gold-brocaded. Anne throws herself at his feet: you can kill me, but preserve my royal dignity. Her guilt is in valuing the throne higher than the noble heart of Percy. Her crime was to think there was no greater bliss than being a King’s wife.
We see Percy and Lord Rochefort (magnificent bass Speedo Ryan Green) imprisoned in the Tower; although reprieved, they determine to die together with the Queen. Rochefort deserves to die, he sings, because he persuaded Anna to aspire to the throne. Percy counters, Albelo’s tenor resplendent, Vivi tu . In their stirring duet, they will defy death. Loudly cheered, the ladies didn’t take all the awards.
By contrast, the Ladies choir in Anna’s closing scene, sing to a very solemn orchestral accompaniment, who can see the poor tormented woman without weeping. Anna is, as if in a delirium, haunted by her thoughts. Al dolce guidami . Gruberova’s voice is fragile, almost breaking. Anna imagines it is her wedding day; and the King awaits her at the altar. Gruberova appears in black, in a doorway, swaying, her ladies grouped around the stage. Anticipating the mad scene in Donizetti’s Lucia di Lammermoor, Anne’s aria is disjointed. She’s dejected, begs forgiveness. What joy! Do not let me die alone…Accompanied by cor anglais, she’s now seated on the stage. Harrowing, heart-rending, Gruberova sings with consummate artistry. The voice of a lifetime’s experience in opera, especially Donizetti roles. The tumultuous applause seemed inappropriate- to the drama, the private anguish.
Then we hear a drum roll. What is that sound? why are they arousing her from her delirium. … the men are dying on her account, Rochefort, her brother, and Percy (who the King promised to save.) A pizzicato strumming: Smeton, where is his harp? The Chorus repeat, ‘Anna, her senses have left her again’. The strings are muffled , ‘like the strings of a dying heart’. Anne sings plaintively, Cielo, a’ miei lunghi spasimi , heaven release me from my suffering .
Tremolo strings: an upbeat brass fanfare, summoning the execution, sounds like a celebration. The people are greeting their Queen, she sings. But as the King’s marriage to Seymour is announced, she calls for heaven’s mercy on the guilty couple. Perhaps not the Anne Boleyn, observed by eye-witnesses, who faced her execution with calm dignity, devoutly reciting her prayers.
It is astonishing that Gruberova- in black, with her hair let down; unruly- looks radiantly young again. A great performance has transformed her like alchemy.
Evelino Pidò conducted Vienna State Opera Orchestra and Choirs. © P.R. 23.10.2015
Photos: Edita Gruberova (Anna Bolena) and Margarita Gritskova (Smeton); Edita Gruberova (Anna) ; Marco Vinco (Enrico VIII); Sonia Ganassi (Giovanna Seymour) ; Featured image : Marco Vinco and Sonia Ganassi
© Wiener Staatsoper/ Michael Poehn

Verdi’s Macbeth at Vienna State Opera

Verdi, like other great 19th Century composers, was inspired by Shakespeare’s plays. Verdi’s Macbeth faithfully follows Shakespeare’s . The focus is on the central characters. The ‘tragedy of Macbeth’ is the fall from grace of the once noble man, who sacrifices all- soul and self-respect- for power. He is egged-on by an over-ambitious wife to gory murders (from the visiting king to his henchman Banquo.) The genius of Shakespeare and Verdi is in showing they pay too high a price: the psychological cost of guilt is despair and madness. Shakespeare’s embittered, world-weary soliloquies – Macbeth’s ‘Out, out brief candle’, and Lady Macbeth’s sleepwalking scene- are transposed by Verdi (and librettist Francesco Piave) into powerful musical arias that broke the operatic mould.
Swirling clouds, smoke billowing as if from a volcano: the backdrop to Verdi’s overture. A whole coven of witches line each side of Vienna’s stage, beneath granite-like walls: divided by a chasm. Verdi’s music is surprisingly spritely -even cheerful. (Vienna State Opera Orchestra excel under Alain Altinoglu.) Never have I seen such a wild and beautiful day, sings Macbeth, (George Petean). He and Banquo (Ferruccio Furlanetto), in (designer) blue camouflage, are like modern-day soldiers.
Mysterious words, comments Macbeth: the witches predict his fortune from general to King; and Banquo ‘not a king , but father of kings’. But black-suited messengers now hail him, as prophesied, Thane of Cawdor. ‘The witches speak the truth,’ sings Petean’s richly complex baritone. Yet why does his hair stand on end. ‘But often the spirits of hell will tell us things to deceive us’, cautions Banquo, Furlanetto’s great Verdi bass celebrating thirty years on the Vienna stage.
The messengers all-in-black, sharply-cut suits and hats, seem out of a film-noir. At first , the outfits seem like a mishmash in Vienna State Opera’s new production of Macbeth. Director Christian Räth has transposed the opera to late 20th century : a modern twist, suggesting some Latin dictatorship. The sets (Gary McCann) for Macbeth’s castle are gloomy concrete minimalism, central staircase discretely lit neon . It works, unless you were expecting tartan kilts. Shakespeare’s (1605) play was located somewhere in the Scottish past: Verdi’s opera (1847, revised 1865) three centuries later. So there is no ‘authentic’ set.
In the letter scene(2) ,the first of Lady Macbeth’s great arias, we see Tatiana Serjan, wearing a figure-hugging silver-grey satin costume. She at first reads the letter (in broken Italian) of how Macbeth met the witches on the day of victory. Then the voice, Serjan’s voluptuous soprano, soars: ‘You are a man of ambition, Macbeth, you strive for greatness.’ She’s singing her innermost thoughts, fired by the prophesy: ‘the witches have procured you Scotland’s throne’. Serjan, a petite brunette, with short modish hair gestures like a mini-potentate. Wonderfully expressive, her coloratura is effortless, but natural: no self-conscious diva mannerisms.
She orders Macbeth, Duncan, coming tonight, must be treated with full kingly honours. But secretly she beckons the foul spirits of night. Vieni! t’affretta! Let the night wrap us in her darkness, hiding the dagger and the heart it pierces. Serjan’s Lady is a feisty modern bitch!
Petean’s Macbeth enters in his greatcoat. Their scene, Verdi’s duet, is the crux of the piece. ‘Don’t you understand!’- ‘And what if I fail in my attempt?’ -‘Come with me now and give him a warm welcome.’ She, the mastermind, has to lead him step by step. This Macbeth, Petean, looks distinguished, a decent man, but he has no imagination: the good guy has to be corrupted.
In his aria- Verdi’s music is ominous- Macbeth is already fearful. Mi si affaccia un pugnal ‘Is this a dagger I see..Your blade draws a trail of blood.’- ‘What was that call?’ We see Tatiana Serjan huddled up, anxious. Verdi makes her plausibly human, no ogre. She has to steel herself for the deed.
Petean’s lyrical baritone (emphasising vulnerability) sings of the voice he’s heard: ‘he shall have nothing but thorns for his pillow’. Serjan’s Lady taunts his whingeing: You are ambitious, but lack courage. He trembles, lashes out, raves. Where is the bold victor of yore?
(After the deed) she has to order him to take the daggers back, and smears them with (Duncan’s) blood. He slobbers, frightened by every word. ‘If only I could banish the crime from my mind.’- ‘Pull yourself together’, she constantly extorts him.
The morning after, Furlanetto’s Banquo, now in a dashing blue uniform, sings of that terrible night, the voices he heard, the bird of ill omen. Macbeth’s modern servants sing repeatedly, ‘Only with thy light are we able to penetrate the veil of darkness.’ Wonderful singing from Vienna State Opera Chorus, Verdi in Verdi. (Macbeth, black-suited, Lady Macbeth in red, deflect the blame onto Malcolm (Duncan’s son,) who escapes to England.)
Verdi’s Act 2 opens to a bedroom scene, the Macbeth’s. ‘There’s more blood to shed!’ Shall Banquo’s children, as prophesied, ascend the throne? Lady Macbeth, straddled over him, is stroking his hair. ‘You won’t change your mind.’ It must be so. Her sexual charms are a potent instrument of persuasion. But in her aria, she exults, invoking rapturous night : ‘Oh, the ecstasy of power. You satisfy every desire.’
The chorus of Verdi’s assassins are Mafiosi- sleek-suited, gabardine raincoats, shades – dark figures against the grimly modernist concrete building. Banquo, full of premonitions, sings, on a night like this , his dear King Duncan was killed. Furlanetto’s magnificent bass, subtly modulated over its wide range, is silenced too soon. The stage is invaded by Macbeth’s mobsters who liquidate their prey.
In the so-called Banquet scene, Serjan , centre stage in scarlet silk gown, raises her glass to the Macbeth’s success; Banish all sorrow, let joy abound. The celebrations are interrupted by Macbeth, remonstrating with Banquo’s ghost (invisible to the party). Is he mad? Be seated, my lord, consider your guests…(But this is a stand-up do, with drinks passed around.) So is it all in his mind ? Christian Rath’s is a modern take. The stage is cast in shadows, as Macbeth drives the spirit away. I am a man again, he boasts. (You should be ashamed, my lord, she remonstrates.) But Petean sings, front-of-stage, the phantom is after his blood, and will have it.
Superstition plays a key role in Macbeth , but Shakespeare and Verdi are as concerned with the psychological workings of their characters. Verdi’s 19th century was fascinated with the gothic and supernatural; whereas a modern audience might read in ‘subconscious’ motivation.
So opening Act 3 (in Räth’s plausibly modern reading), Macbeth lies in bed; around him, witches move, casting their spells. Is it a dream? What are you doing here, you secretive witches. But he still wants to know his fate. Effectively staged, we see the spectre of the crowned King looming over a small boy chalking a sketch of the branches of a tree. This becomes a symbol of the budding revolt against Macbeth: finally, the branches (Birnam Wood) camouflage Malcolm’s soldiers marching on Macbeth’s castle.
Macbeth, in Verdi’s aria, imagines the sons of Macduff, wearing his crown, occupying the throne: And you are not even alive, you horrors! Petean appears to faint. The witches warn Macbeth beware of Macduff (‘not by woman born’). Black-hooded figures chalk up the branch symbol backstage . Chorus sing of their downtrodden fatherland. They are led by Macduff, magnificently sung by tenor Jorge de León, a highlight aria bewailing his children murdered by tyrants: In vain they cried out to him, where he’d fled. ‘Our Fatherland betrayed, may Gd’s wrath destroy the villain’. A line of exiles -Macduff, Malcolm- stand together, invoking their oppressed country, Ah, la paterna mano , in what could be a Risorgimento anthem.
Lady Macbeth’s sleepwalking scene is preceded by mournful clarinet and oboe. Una maccia è qui tuttoria, her obsession with cleaning the blood from her hands- not all the perfumes of Arabia can sweeten them- is nothing less than Freudian. Who would have thought the old man would have so much blood? Serjan’s Lady Macbeth is outstanding . Harrowing, low-key -this cannot be the diva – she is stripped back to the vulnerable, pitiful, pathos-ridden woman.
Macbeth, in his battle-cry against traitors, stands defiant. Yet, in his aria, he feels the life in his veins draining away from him. Petean sings sotto voce of Pietta, rispetta, amore , he waits in vain for compassion, respect; but, repeatedly, ‘miserable wretch, curses alone shall be your funeral dirge.’ Plaintively, beautifully sung.
A truly glorious brass section (a trumpet voluntary) announcing Vittoria, radiant the hero (Macduff) who kills the traitor. Glorious Verdi choruses! Never mind Shakespeare’s speeches- Malcolm’s appeal to his countrymen for reconciliation- Verdi’s music says it all. It’s all over in a chorus. © P.R. 21.10.2015
Photos: Tatiana Serjan (Lady Macbeth) and George Petean (Macbeth); George Petean and Tatiana Serjan; Ferrucio Furlanetto (Banquo) and Jongmin Park (Spy); George Petean (Macbeth)
© Wiener Staatsoper/ Michael Pöhn